To succeed in short selling over time, investors need to consistently identify and target losing stocks, which is often more difficult than benefiting from the general upward movement of the market. The profit is the difference between the selling price and the repurchase price, minus fees. It’s commonly used by experienced traders looking to profit during market downturns or from overvalued stocks. Short selling is a trading strategy where an investor bets that a stock’s price will decline. Understand that the mechanics of short selling are very different than for buying stocks, as are the risk profiles. This forced buying by the short sellers causes the stock price rise to accelerate, forcing other short sellers to join in the panic buying.
Is short selling ethical?
Understanding fundamental analysis is key to seeing how they pick their targets and, in doing so, make the market more efficient. Melvin Capital alone lost an estimated $6.8 billion in a single month—a staggering 53% of its capital—and had to be bailed out by other funds. Figuring out how to short sell effectively requires strategic planning and extensive market knowledge to identify potential stock weaknesses. Common identification techniques include analyzing charting patterns, moving averages, and the relative strength index (RSI).
The Advantages of Short Selling
However, shorting carries high risk—if the stock rises instead, losses can be unlimited. You should also avoid heavily shorted stocks that would put you at risk of getting short squeezed. So, the idea behind buying a put option is similar to shorting, although the most you can possibly lose is what you pay for the put option. Now, there’s more to trading options than I can explain here, so do your homework if this is a strategy that sounds appealing to you. But it can be a smart alternative to the unlimited loss exposure that comes with shorting a stock. But when used in moderation, short selling can diversify your investment exposure and give you an opportunity to capture better returns than someone who only owns stocks and other investments.
Bankrate logo
- By digging into these extreme examples, we can get a much better feel for the high-stakes game of betting against a stock and the powerful market forces that can turn the tables in an instant.
- So the most you could profit in a short position is the initial value of the stock you shorted.
- When you place a short sell order, the brokerage system automatically locates and borrows the shares from its inventory or another client’s holdings.
- It’s quite common for long-term stock investors to earn profits that are several times the size of their initial investment.
- However, timing and stock selection become crucial during declining markets.
- For example, compare the potential gain on buying 100 shares of fictional ABC stock trading at $100 per share.
If 50% of a portfolio with a close correlation to the S&P 500 is hedged, and the index moves up 15% over the next 12 months, the portfolio would only record approximately half of that gain, or 7.5%. This buying frenzy sent the stock price into the stratosphere, launching it from under $20 to over $480 in just a few weeks. It was an audacious bet, and for a long time, an incredibly painful one.
The ethics of short selling
Most forms of market manipulation like this are illegal in the U.S. but may still happen periodically. Ultimately, short selling is a necessary piece of a dynamic market, providing balance, liquidity, and a crucial dose of skepticism. Short selling allows market participants to express a pessimistic view, which is essential for accurate price discovery.
Given the risks, short sellers have to be unusually careful and well informed, lest they stumble into a stock that’s about to bound higher for years. So short selling is usually best left to sophisticated investors who have tons of research, deep pockets and a higher risk tolerance. On the other hand, some very public short sellers are happy to spread rumors or opinions that try to discredit profitable companies and scare the market into selling them.
Short selling can compromise people’s confidence in the market and may negatively impact companies and their investors, as it does involve selling stocks that you don’t technically own. Still, if you’re set on betting against a stock, you may be able to use put options to limit the worst risk of shorting (namely, uncapped losses). One strategy (buying a put option) allows you to profit on the decline of a stock and limit how much you’ll lose on the position. Options present other risks, however, that investors need to be fully aware of before they start trading them. Yet short selling can limit the rise of stocks and prevent them from running into a speculative frenzy, helping the market maintain order. Furthermore, short sellers can bring an additional positive to the market by providing greater liquidity.
In this case, you’ll have to put more cash in your account or liquidate positions, or if you’re unable to do so, your broker may liquidate positions for you. You may be forced to close your short position against your wishes. Unexpected news events can initiate a short squeeze, forcing short sellers to buy at any price to cover their margin requirements. For example, due to a short squeeze, Volkswagen briefly became the most valuable publicly traded company on Earth.
On the flip side, your potential loss is theoretically unlimited. Getting a handle on these costs and obligations is non-negotiable. It’s what allows you to manage a short sale responsibly and know when to adjust your strategy as market conditions change. Since you’re buying them back at a lower price than you sold them for, you lock in a profit. The difference between the initial sale price and the lower repurchase price (minus fees) is yours to keep.
The High-Stakes Game of Risk and Reward
If your prediction was right and the stock price drops, you “cover” your position by buying back the same number of shares you originally borrowed. The most critical is maintaining the required equity level in your margin account. If the trade goes against you and your collateral drops too low, you’ll face a dreaded margin call. Beyond these individual motivations, short selling also plays a role in the market itself by adding liquidity and contributing to price discovery, essentially helping to keep overhyped stocks in check.
The GameStop Saga: A Short Squeeze Disaster
Short selling requires a lot of work and knowledge to succeed, and it’s not really a good idea for individual investors, who must match their wits against some of the sharpest investing minds. Given the challenges, even many of the professionals find shorting to be a grueling effort. When you short a stock, you rack up a margin What is Ripple loan for the value of the stock you’ve borrowed.
The stock can continue rising over years if the company is well run. There’s literally no cap on the upside of a stock, and stocks have made millionaires out of many people over time. Another downside of shorting a stock is that you have less potential gain than going long with the stock. A rise in short interest can alert investors to potential problems, prompting further research or caution. If you choose to “buy to cover,” the broker repurchases the same number of shares on your behalf and returns them to the lender.
- Now, there’s more to trading options than I can explain here, so do your homework if this is a strategy that sounds appealing to you.
- The stock can continue rising over years if the company is well run.
- You, as the trader, decide how long to hold the short position based on your market view.
- Those with a bearish view can borrow shares on margin and sell them in the market, hoping to repurchase them at some point in the future at a lower price.
- In a coordinated effort, they started buying up shares and call options, intentionally sparking a historic short squeeze.
Your profit is capped at 100%, and that is if the stock literally falls all the way to zero. Let’s assume you believe shares of Microsoft (MSFT) are overpriced and you expect the price to decline in value. As a final thought, an alternative to shorting that limits your downside exposure is to buy a put option on a stock. Build long-term wealth using The Motley Fool’s market-beating method. For them, lending those shares out is a simple, low-risk way to generate extra income.
The stock’s rise creates rapid losses, showcasing the danger of incorrect timing or surprise events. They buy back the shares for $5,000 and pocket the $3,000 difference (excluding fees). If you are an experienced investor comfortable with taking and controlling risk, there is absolutely nothing wrong with shorting a stock. You can potentially lose your entire investment, but you can’t lose more. You pay cash to buy shares from an existing shareholder looking to sell, and your broker handles the details behind the scenes. Essentially, a put option gives you the right — but not the obligation — to sell a stock at a predetermined price (known as the strike price) at any time before the option contract expires.
